Skip to main content

Table 2 Comparison of True Genomic Values estimations

From: Comparison of analyses of the XVth QTLMAS common dataset III: Genomic Estimations of Breeding Values

First author

Label

r

rank

bias

MSE

Shariati

BayesS_1

0.86

0.53

0.89

7.51

 

BayesS_2

0.86

0.53

0.89

7.52

 

BayesS_3

0.86

0.53

0.88

7.85

 

BayesS_4

0.85

0.55

0.87

8.00

Ogutu

RR

0.85

0.54

1.19

8.44

 

GBLUP_O

0.90

0.52

1.11

5.55

 

LASSO_O

0.92

0.63

1.09

4.67

 

LASSO_ad

0.92

0.62

1.02

4.30

 

EN

0.92

0.62

1.23

4.96

 

EN_ad

0.90

0.40

0.97

5.48

Wang

BayesA_W

0.92

0.65

1.06

4.15

 

BayesB_W

0.93

0.70

1.05

3.66

 

BayesCπ_W

0.93

0.70

1.06

3.63

 

TABLUP

0.91

0.68

0.97

4.59

 

GBLUP_W

0.78

0.37

1.20

11.71

Mucha

AM

0.61

0.36

1.06

17.57

 

FM

0.49

0.32

0.35

43.17

 

RM1

0.70

0.38

1.77

16.65

 

RM2

0.71

0.38

1.69

16.30

Zeng

GBLUPa_Z

0.82

0.53

1.04

8.94

 

GBLUPd_Z

0.81

0.52

1.04

9.46

 

BayesB _W

0.93

0.71

1.05

3.63

 

BayesCπ_W

0.94

0.72

1.07

3.41

Usai

LASSO_Uc

0.92

0.62

1.25

5.04

 

LASSO_Uc1

0.90

0.64

1.02

5.30

 

LASSO_Uc2

0.92

0.63

1.09

4.66

Schurink

BayesZ

0.90

0.60

1.06

5.20

  1. r=Pearson correlation between TGV and GEBV, rank=rank correlation of the best 10% TGV, bias = regression coefficient between TGV and GEBV, MSEP= mean squared error of prediction of TGV by GEBV.